Series: The Knots Sequence

The Shadow’s Curse by Amy McCulloch – Review

The Shadow’s Curse by Amy McCulloch – ReviewThe Shadow's Curse by Amy McCulloch
Series: The Knots Sequence #2
Also in this series: Oathbreaker's Shadow
Format: ARC
Pages: 480 pages
Genres: Epic Fantasy, Young Adult
Buy from AmazonKoboiTunes
Evelynne's rating: four-stars

The Shadow’s Curse by Amy McCulloch is the second and final book in her Knots Sequence duology and follows on from Oathbreaker’s Shadow.  I received a free copy from Random House of Canada in exchange for an honest review.  I have previously reviewed the first in the series – check out my review here.  

The novel takes up where we left off in the earlier book with Raim seeking to learn the history of his mysterious broken vow as well as to rescue his friend Wadi.  It has been a while since I read Oathbreaker’s Shadow and for a couple of pages I was a little confused.  However, McCulloch quickly and skillfully recapped the main points so that I was soon up to speed.

What I liked

Tight narrative structure.  The Shadow’s Curse switches between two points of view, Raim’s and Wadi’s, following two converging main storylines.  Wadi’s storyline also serves to present the main antagonist’s, Kareh’s, story.  This works well to create tension for the inevitable confrontation when these paths come together.  Both Raim and Wadi are working towards specific goals.  In Raim’s case, this aim is explicitly stated early on – to rid himself of his oathbreaker stigma – whereas Wadi’s purpose is not revealed until later.  This structure keeps the novel’s pace moving along briskly and creates good narrative tension,

Payoff from book one. Oathbreaker’s Shadow had left me a little frustrated that there had been so little payoff for the setup.  This is remedied in The Shadow’s Curse in which the central premise of Raim’s broken vow is explored in much more satisfying depth.  For this reason I would suggest that you read both as one long story.

The worldbuilding.  I really enjoyed the world that McCulloch created with the taboo around oathbreaking and the haunts.  In The Shadow’s Curse this is explored in greater depth as Raim and Draikh learn to work together.  We also explore new parts of this world which was interesting too.  The contrast between the nomadic North and the more settled South was intriguing.  

What I didn’t like

Bland characters.  I continued to be far more invested in the world in which the characters find themselves rather than in the characters themselves. For me though, the interesting world more than balanced this out.

I thought The Shadow’s Curse was a solid end to the Knots Sequence duology and I gave it four stars out of five.

 buy from Amazon, Kobo, iTunes, eBooks.com

four-stars

Oathbreaker’s Shadow by Amy McCulloch

Oathbreaker’s Shadow by Amy McCullochOathbreaker's Shadow by Amy McCulloch
Series: The Knots Sequence #1
Also in this series: The Shadow's Curse
Format: ARC
Pages: 416
Genres: Young Adult
Evelynne's rating: three-half-stars

I received a free review copy of Oathbreaker’s Shadow via Netgalley.  Oathbreaker’s Shadow is a young adult fantasy novel by Canadian writer Amy McCulloch.  It tells the story of Raim and how he falls foul of his society’s taboo against pathbreaking.  A key part of the novel is Raim’s friendship with the young heir to the realm.

(more…)

three-half-stars
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers