Canadian eReader http://canadianereader.com E-reader and book reviews Wed, 15 May 2019 23:46:34 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=4.5.31 52291287 How I’d Fix Game of Thrones Season 8 – SPOILERS! http://canadianereader.com/2019/05/15/how-id-fix-game-of-thrones-season-8-spoilers/ http://canadianereader.com/2019/05/15/how-id-fix-game-of-thrones-season-8-spoilers/#respond Wed, 15 May 2019 23:46:34 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=13376 So guys, I know I’ve not written much lately, but I feel compelled to write given my strong reaction to Season 8 of Game of Thrones.  Full disclosure; this post is being written after the first five episodes have aired but before the series finale.  

It’s no secret that the audience reaction to this final season has been less than positive to say the least.  Many of the writing choices made by the showrunners have come under heavy fire with the main criticism being that they have sacrificed character development for spectacle.  Unfortunately, I can’t say I disagree with popular opinion.  It’s a shame as the source material is excellent and the production values of the show are outstanding.  Each and every person involved in the show has given their all to it, but that doesn’t balance some serious errors of judgment in writing.

All that being said, I have given a lot of thought about changes I would make to the season to improve it.  My goal here is to make as few changes as possible while better serving the overall narrative and character development.

The most significant cause of criticism and for me the biggest writing error was the decision to neutralise the White Walker threat only half way through the season.  This was the big life extinction event threat that has been teased since the prologue of season one.  Additionally the apocalypse was diverted by means of a plot device that many felt was unjustified leaving many to feel the resolution was unearned.

Like many, I’m really not happy that Arya killed the Night King.  There are two main overarching story arcs in the show.  The first is the Game of Thrones, the fight for control of Westeros and the right to sit on the Iron Throne.  The second is the Song of Ice and Fire or the impending White Walker attack.  Arya’s story throughout the books and the first seven seasons has been about learning her assassin skills to avenge her family for their losses in the Game of Thrones.  Now maybe I’m misunderstanding here, but she has never expressed an interest in becoming involved in the Great War against the White Walkers.  The prophecies linked to the Great War also seem to point to Jon not Arya as the solution.

Since they chose to ignore prophesy for time constraints or another reason and go that route, I have a few suggestions to improve the plotline. They should have owned it.  In show they should have discussed it and realised that the Night King cannot be defeated by military means and that an Arya assassination is the Hail Mary solution, the throwing of the Ring into Mount Doom. The whole Bran bait trap would still work as currently in the show.  Jon would explicitly accept that his role in the Night King’s defeat is to fight to ensure that the NK doesn’t sense a trap and that enough of the living survive to matter – Aragorn to Arya’s Frodo if you like.    

They’d need to find a way to have Arya not be positioned in the Godswood straight off, but otherwise her story could play out very similarly.  There would still be a lot of tension about will she make it?  Beric’s death would mean more since we know what it was buying; Arya’s chance to do her thing.  There would be no need for Mel to tell us why; we would be shown why it mattered.  Arya’s losing courage would make sense knowing what she was facing and Mel could still do her bolstering.  We could also get that lovely scene with Bran and Theon, thinking that Arya didn’t make it, and then when she does her ninja act and succeeds it will feel more earned.  Also with Jon’s role being clear, there would be less frustration at his being useless.  Heck there is even no need to cut his struggling to reach Bran in the Godswood in the belief that Arya had failed.  I would also have Arya die, emphasising the cost of killing the Night King. 

On other matters.  I would also have Brienne and Jaime consummate their relationship BEFORE the battle.   Brienne would die in the battle sadly, witnessed by Jaime. This would explain his motivation for buggering off back to Kings Landing.  What’s the point of fighting for honour when honourable people like Brienne die anyway?  There would be nothing left for him but to return to Cersei.  It would still be unclear if he plans to kill her or kiss her.  Brienne’s death would really mean something and Jaime’s character arc would not be butchered as much.  I understand that they were going for a theme of Cersei’s an addiction that Jaime couldn’t beat, and maybe that will play out in the books but much better written. Rheagal the dragon would also die in the Battle of Winterfell. 

If Arya didn’t die killing the Night King, she and the Hound should have had their “Sandor… thank you” conversation back in Winterfell.  Arya’s main arc is done now.  There is no need for her in Kings Landing.  Cersei and Euron should have fallen more easily.  Euron should not have been able to kill a dragon with his super ballistae.  Dany would have destroyed the Iron Fleet as she did.  Cersei and Qyburn would talk about setting off the wildfire caches setting up a Cersei Mad Queen expectation to be subverted by Dany.  The Varys/Tyrion/Dany/Jon betrayal arc could play out very similarly. 

The whole battle for Kings Landing could play out as on screen but with one key difference.  Dany orders Jon to bring her Cersei dead or alive personally.  This means that we’re following Jon rather than Arya throughout the destruction of Kings Landing.  Arya’s only purpose was to have someone sympathetic to follow, which is now fulfilled by Jon.  It adds an element of does Dany want to take out multiple claimants to the Iron Throne in one swoop?  Additionally, by having Jon witness the carnage at such close quarters, even he cannot be stupid enough to ignore what Dany has become. Heck you can even have him ride off on that white horse if you like.

I would make a change to Cleganebowl; it should have been made crystal clear that the Hound makes a conscious choice to face his fear of fire to take out his brother. 

I’ve still not decided on how to fix the Jaime/Cersei ending.  Any suggestions?

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2019/05/15/how-id-fix-game-of-thrones-season-8-spoilers/feed/ 0 13376
Evelynne’s Reading Year and Anticipating 2019 http://canadianereader.com/2018/12/29/evelynnes-reading-year-and-anticipating-2019/ http://canadianereader.com/2018/12/29/evelynnes-reading-year-and-anticipating-2019/#respond Sun, 30 Dec 2018 01:18:04 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=13269 Hello, and I know it’s been a while…  Life caught up with me with new responsibilities at work and home, working towards my CCNA qualification (until said new responsibilities put a halt to it.)  Anyway, enough excuses.  Here I am with my reading review of 2018.

2018 in Stats

I use GoodReads as my book tracking application of choice.  I read primarily on my Kindle and since Amazon bought GoodReads the integration works really well.  Let me share the image that captures my main statistics:

Year in books

As you can see, in 2018 I read 53 books, which beat my GoodReads challenge of 45 books – yay!  The shortest book I read was Percy Jackson and the Singer of Apollo at only 28 pages and the longest was Kingdom of Ash at 992 pages.  I’ll be honest; this has not been my greatest reading year. It is the lowest book count since 2010 when I started tracking my reading on GoodReads and nowhere near my record of 117 books that I read in 2013.  Admittedly, 2013 was boosted considerably by my tendency to listen to audiobooks to keep me awake during my long nightshifts.

Additionally, there are not so many books I read this year that blew me away.  I was actually struggling to find enough to fit in a top 5.  It was rare this year to find a book that had me sneaking a quick read at my Kindle during breaks and commutes.  Can you say reading slump?  A fair number of the books I read were also non fiction to prepare myself for my promotion to management this year.  See: increased responsibilities.  

Nevertheless, here are some books that rocked my world in 2018.

Evelynne’s Five Top Picks of 2018

Book of Life Trilogy + Time’s Convert by Deborah Harkness.  I’m grouping these as one plus the followup book as I marathoned all of these in November 2018.  I remember I tried to read the first book a couple of years ago and couldn’t get into it at all.  I tried again this year and couldn’t put it down.  While I didn’t love the characters and their relationship, I LOVED the world building and the historical basis for Harkness’s world.  I simply ate them all up.  It helped of course that Sky UK made a wonderful TV adaptation (which I caught on UK iTunes) starring Matthew Goode and Teresa Palmer plus an excellent supporting cast.  Those of you who have to wait for the Stateside release of the show are in for a real treat.

I’m aware that the follow on novel, Time’s Convert, had mixed reviews, but again I loved it.  The contrast between Marcus’s experiences in the 1800s and Phoebe’s modern day experience was so very well done.

Queen of Air and Darkness by Cassandra Clare.  I admit I had some reservations awaiting this book.  It is the conclusion to Clare’s Dark Artifices series and I had been very unhappy with how she closed off her Mortal Instruments series.  While QoA&D is not quite as satisfying as Clockwork Princess, the conclusion to The Infernal Devices, I felt Clare did an excellent job at servicing her characters and closing off plot lines. The hook at the end made me really excited for the next series, The Wicked Powers.

Children of Blood and Bone by Tomi Adeyemi.  Yes, I know I came to the party late with this one, having only read it this month.  I must admit I was a little unsure as it was marketed as predominantly based on African mythology; being of European descent I am more used to stories based on European folklore.  Often with new authors or books I’m not sure about I will check out a sample from Amazon or Audible.  In this case when I read the sample I was immediately hooked.  I loved the characters, the world and the magic system.  I particularly enjoyed that some of the characters were written in shades of grey.  It was not clear which way they’d go. I’d thoroughly recommend this one and can’t wait for the sequel.

Grim Lovelies by Megan Shepherd This one had me at transfigured animals in modern day Paris. Again I loved the setting, the characters and the magic system. Shepherd also makes use of an old cliche of a timer running down but it worked incredibly well here.  I can’t wait to read the sequel.

Vox by Christina Dalcher  This is one of the few non YA non fantasy books to top my list this year.  Having loved the adaptation of Margaret Attwood’s Handmaid’s Tale, I was intrigued by this novel which describes a world in which women’s voices are restricted, literally and figuratively by a word counter.  It wasn’t always an easy read, given the world in which we are living, but it was fascinating to see how it was developed and the impact the lack of voice had on society.

Most anticipated releases of 2019

Here, in no particular order, are five books I’m anxiously anticipating in 2019.

Courting Darkness by Robin LaFevers,  This is the first in a new duology (duologies really are the new trilogies!) and is a followup to the marvellous His Fair Assassin trilogy.  This centres around an order of assassin nuns and is such a fun read – I am looking forward to seeing how the story continues.  Courting Darkness will be released on February 5th 2019.

The Ruin of Kings by Jenn Lyons.  This is the first in a new epic fantasy series.  I must admit I was a little concerned about committing to a new epic fantasy series.  I’m already following Brandon Sanderson’s Stormlight Archive, and I’m not sure how many books Lyons is anticipating in her series.  However, Tor.com is releasing a couple of chapters a week along with commentary from the inimitable Leigh Butler.  I’ve been following along and really enjoying Lyons’ witty, engaging prose and characters.  I look forward to reading it when it hits shelves and Kindles on February 5th 2019.

Children of Virtue and Vengeance by Tomi Adeyemi.  This is the sequel to Children of Blood and Bone which I have just finished and look forward to seeing where the story goes next.  If it’s as engaging as the first volume it should be a fantastic read.  Children of Virtue and Vengeance is released on March 5th so not too far away.

Holy Sister by Mark Lawrence.  This is the finale to Lawrence’s Book of the Ancestor coincidentally also about warrior nuns.  Are they also a thing now?  Lawrence’s finale to The Broken Empire is one of of my all-time favourite series conclusions so if he can do the same for this one I’ll be very very happy.  Holy Sister is released on April 9th 2019.

The Testaments by Margaret Attwood.  After decades, Attwood is finally publishing a sequel to The Handmaid’s Tale!  I am sooooo excited to read this.  I imagine Attwood’s decision to write and publish this now is due to the success of the TV adaptation and also the changes in the world in which we live.  This sequel takes place 15 years after the ending of the first book, which is a very smart move; that way it won’t contradict the narrative of the TV series.  I’ll definitely be queuing up to read this when it is released on September 10th 2019.

So there you have it; my reading year and my most anticipated reads for 2019.  How did they compare with yours?  Let me know in the comments.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2018/12/29/evelynnes-reading-year-and-anticipating-2019/feed/ 0 13269
King of Ashes by Raymond E. Feist – Spoiler free review http://canadianereader.com/2018/04/22/king-of-ashes/ http://canadianereader.com/2018/04/22/king-of-ashes/#respond Sun, 22 Apr 2018 19:23:29 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=10203 King of Ashes is the first in a new series by fantasy author Raymond E. Feist and is the first not to be set in his Midkemia setting.  My thanks to HarperCollins Canada and Raymond E. Feist for the early eArc.  King of Ashes is released on May 8th and as such I will keep this review as spoiler-free as possible.

On a personal note, I credit Mr. Feist with reawakening my love of reading; after studying literature at university I couldn’t stand to read anything more involved than a Cosmo magazine. Then a friend put a copy of Shadow of a Dark Queen into my hands and I’ve not stopped reading since.  He is a master storyteller.  It’s always “have to read one more page, one more chapter.” then before you know it, it’s 6am and you have to get ready to go to work…

For those of you unfamiliar with Feist’s earlier work, there are 30 novels in his Riftwar series starting with 1982’s Magician and ending with 2013’s Magician’s End.  My personal recommendation is to start with Magician as a good introduction to the world – be aware it does drag in parts – or the four books of the Serpentwar Saga – storytelling at its finest.

Anyway, onto King of Ashes.  This is set in the new world of Garn and centres around two young men, Hatu, the unknowing secret heir of the betrayed King Steveran and Declan, a young blacksmith at the peak of his craft.  Events force our two protagonists to flee their homes and plunges them into an adventure that promises to change their lives and the future of Garn itself..

Worldbuilding.  Naturally, it’s not reasonable to expect a world that is as fully developed as Midkemia, on which Feist worked for over 30 years.  That said, there are clear indications that a lot of thought has gone into Garn already and that it is going to be a wonderful place to get to know.  There are distinct cultures, history and religions and I look forward to seeing how the place grows.  One aspect I would have liked to have seen developed more fully at this point is the magic system.  In the whole 512 pages, it is only touched upon briefly, although there are definite hints of magical forces.

Characters.  I enjoyed spending time with both our protagonists, probably more so Declan than Hatu.  Both characters had distinct arcs in the story, although it was clear they are both still at the beginning of their journeys.  I look forward to seeing where they go from here.  The supporting characters were also interesting, and well developed, and a couple of them led to intriguing hooks for book two.  it’s too early to say yet whether either of them will be a Pug, a Jimmy the Hand or a Miranda from the earlier series.

Plot.  I would say that the focus of King of Ashes is on worldbuilding and character development, somewhat to the detriment of plot.  As the first book in a new series, especially one set in a new world, there is a great deal of heavy lifting to do in order to set the scene.  Much of the storyline seems to be focused in getting characters and plot points in place for the next stage of the saga.  As as self-contained story, I didn’t find King of Ashes particularly satisfying, but I have great faith that it will pay off in future books. 

In summary, if you are hoping that King of Ashes will be a great stand alone story you may be disappointed.  It is very obviously the setup for greater things to come and as such I personally feel it is worth the investment.  

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2018/04/22/king-of-ashes/feed/ 0 10203
I’m so excited… and I just can’t hide it! http://canadianereader.com/2018/04/05/im-so-excited-and-i-just-cant-hide-it/ http://canadianereader.com/2018/04/05/im-so-excited-and-i-just-cant-hide-it/#respond Thu, 05 Apr 2018 22:37:43 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=10158 Thank you so much to HarperCollins Canada and Raymond E. Feist for the eArc of King of Ashes. I’m SOOOOO excited to read this.

I credit Mr. Feist with reawakening my love of reading; after studying literature at university I couldn’t stand to read anything more involved than a Cosmo magazine. Then a friend put a copy of Shadow of a Dark Queen into my hands and I’ve not stopped reading since.  He is a master storyteller.  It’s always “have to read one more page, one more chapter.” then before you know it, it’s 6am and you have to get ready to go to work…

The Riftwar Saga was also the first books I migrated to ebook format when I got my very first Kindle, so you can understand the place Mr. Feist holds in my heart.  You can certainly expect a review of King of Ashes once I have finished it.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2018/04/05/im-so-excited-and-i-just-cant-hide-it/feed/ 0 10158
Doctor Who – Ranking the Regenerations http://canadianereader.com/2018/01/01/doctor-ranking-regenerations/ http://canadianereader.com/2018/01/01/doctor-ranking-regenerations/#respond Tue, 02 Jan 2018 01:17:27 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=9854 Hello, as a Doctor Who fan who has just watched the Twelfth Doctor regenerate into the character’s first female incarnation, I thought it would be a good time to rank them in my estimation.  My rankings are purely personal, and are based on a mixture of the storylines, the performances and the whole caboodle.

14 Sixth Doctor to Seventh Doctor, Time and the Rani 1987 (Colin Baker to Sylvester McCoy)
Cause of regeneration: fatally injured in a TARDIS crash caused by the Rani

Coming in at the bottom spot, we have the regeneration from Six to Seven.  This really is pretty bad as a regeneration story.  Due to conflict between Baker and the BBC, he did not come back to film his regeneration scene or even tie up his era.  Instead we were given McCoy in a blond wig.  Awful  In addition, because of this, the regeneration story was very underwhelming.  No build up, no farewell to the outgoing Doctor.  A poor showing all round.

13 Third Doctor to Fourth Doctor, Planet of the Spiders 1974 (Jon Pertwee to Tom Baker)
Cause of regeneration: fatally poisoned by radiation

I have no strong feelings on this particular storyline.  

12 Fourth Doctor to Fifth Doctor, Logopolis 1981 (Tom Baker to Peter Davison)
Cause of regeneration: fall from the lighthouse

Again I have little to say about this regeneration.  It’s most notable for the Fourth Doctor’s final words “It is the end; but the moment has been prepared for.”

11 Fifth Doctor to Sixth Doctor, The Caves of Androzani 1984 (Peter Davison to Colin Baker)

Cause of regeneration: spectrox poisoning

The Caves of Androzani is widely considered to be one of Davison’s best performances and I agree.  This regeneration is notable for the distinctly uncomfortable feeling of the Sixth Doctor’s first words about change and not being a moment too soon.  This is clearly a new Doctor to be wary of.

10 Second Doctor to Third Doctor, The War Games 1969 (Patrick Troughton to Jon Pertwee)
Cause of regeneration: forced regeneration by the Time Lords due to breaking time lord protocol

This is an unusual regeneration storyline in that the incoming Doctor was not introduced in the regeneration episode.  I’ll be honest and say I’m not so familiar with this regeneration storyline, having only seen the minutes of the regeneration.  I don’t have much to say about it really.

9 Eleventh Doctor to Twelfth Doctor, The Time of the Doctor 2013 (Matt Smith to Peter Capaldi)
Cause of regeneration: old age

Of the reboot regenerations, this is definitely the weakest, which is a shame as I really liked Matt Smith’s Doctor.  The two big issues I found were; 1) they had a powerful storyline here with Eleven believing he was at the end of his regeneration cycle and would die for reals this time around.  They diluted that strong storyline with a whole bunch of crap.  Secondly, having Matt’s Doctor age to become an old man meant that Smith had to wear a lot of prosthetics and makeup which impacted his performance.  Still, on the positive side, his final monologue was beautiful.

8 Seventh Doctor to Eighth Doctor, Doctor Who, the Movie 1996 (Sylvester McCoy to Paul McGann)

Cause of regeneration: shot by a street gang and died due to the human doctor not understanding his Gallifreyan physiology

I’m happy Sylvester McCoy got the opportunity to say goodbye to his Doctor and I’m sad that McGann only got to play the role on screen in this movie and the webisode.  Nothing much to add.

7 Tenth Doctor to Tenth Doctor, The Stolen Earth 2008 (David Tennant)

Cause of regeneration: shot by a Dalek

This was a lovely fake-out regeneration, although it is still officially a new regeneration.  In essence the Doctor was shot by a Dalek, and started to regenerate, which was the cliffhanger at the end of part one of a two-part story.  Of course people were pretty shocked – normally when a Doctor leaves it’s announced well in advance.

6 War Doctor to Ninth Doctor, Day of the Doctor 2013 (John Hurt to Christopher Eccleston)
Cause of regeneration: similar to First Doctor, body growing old after the trials of the Time War

I liked this regeneration because it filled in the missing gap.  As Ecclestone was involved in the series reboot where his Doctor was already in place we never got to see his regeneration until eight years later.  I would have liked to have seen more of the Ninth Doctor’s first moments, but this is what we got.

5 Ninth Doctor to Tenth Doctor, The Parting of the Ways 2005 (Christopher Eccleston to David Tennant)
Cause of regeneration: absorption of the Time Vortex

This is of course the first regeneration of the new reboot.  They did some nice effects for the regeneration which continued into the other regeneration scenes in the show.  I enjoyed the storyline which is a typical Doctor sacrifices himself to save his Companion.  Nothing much else to add.

4 Tenth Doctor to Eleventh Doctor, The End of Time 2009 (David Tennant to Matt Smith)
Cause of regeneration: radiation absorption

David Tennant was one of the most popular Doctors of the modern era, and they made a big deal out of his departure.  Tennant’s last series was a collection of specials and his departure storyline was threaded through all of them.  I did feel though that they did milk the departure a little too much with a rerun of Ten’s greatest hits so to speak.  It was a regeneration specifically crafted to tug at the heartstrings.  It did have a beautiful score by Murray Gold – I adore Vale Decem.

3 Twelfth Doctor to Thirteenth Doctor, Twice Upon a Time 2017 (Peter Capaldi to Jodie Whittaker)

Cause of regeneration: electrocuted by a Mondasian Cyberman

Coming in at number 3 we have Twice Upon a Time, the most recent regeneration story.  Of the modern era (post 2005) this is my favourite, perhaps because I saw it so recently.  I loved the interaction between the First Doctor and Twelve and their common theme of rejecting regeneration.  I would have liked to have seen that given a bit more emphasis rather than the Testimony, but whatever.  Capaldi’s last monologue as Twelve was beautiful – moving, appropriate and the delivery was perfect.  “Laugh hard.  Run fast.  Be kind.  Doctor, I let you go.  “  A fitting end to Capaldi’s time on the show.

2 Eighth Doctor to War Doctor, Night of the Doctor webisode 2013 (Paul McGann to John Hurt)

Cause of regeneration:  assisted regeneration after a starship crash.

Eight’s regeneration into the War Doctor comes in at my number 2 spot.  McGann’s inclusion in the fiftieth anniversary celebrations in the webisode The Night of the Doctor was unexpected and wonderful.  I loved this regeneration story for several reasons.  First, we got to fill in a gap in Doctor Who lore; seeing Eight’s regeneration.  Secondly, in Eight’s salute to his companions from the Big Finish audiobooks confirms his stories as canon which is excellent.Thirdly, I loved the concept of assisted regeneration and the fact that the Doctor got some say in his next incarnation.  

Mostly though, I loved it because of seeing the growth in Eight’s character.  When we last saw him on screen seven years previously in the Doctor Who movie, the Eighth Doctor was a lighthearted alien who danced with joy because his shoes fitted so perfectly.  Here in the webisode we see a time lord beaten down by the struggles of the Time War, who still clung to peace and wanted to do his best for everyone, even those who hated him.  This really intrigued me and I was very motivated to learn more about this character and what brought him to this place.  This was the point at which I started listening to the Big Finish audio productions.  If you aren’t familiar with them, check them out.

1 First Doctor to Second Doctor, The Tenth Planet 1966 (William Hartnell to Patrick Troughton)
Cause of regeneration: Original body getting old

At first glance, this isn’t a particularly exciting regeneration story.  The Doctor has been in his original incarnation for a while and his body is wearing a bit thin.  There is no dramatic conflict imperilling his life.  1960s special effects mean that the regeneration scene itself is pretty basic.  In actual fact, we only have a few moments of it as the episode was lost due to the BBC purge of videotapes.  

The reason this is my number one pick is because of what it started.  Without this story and concept, Doctor Who would never have survived to celebrate its 50th anniversary. The concept of regeneration to replace a lead actor with someone who looks and acts in a completely different manner is nothing short of brilliant.  And in a time without the internet and spoilers, can you imagine the shock value?  This gives the show a fresh perspective every few years and I believe that has contributed to the show’s longevity.  1960s showrunners, I salute you.

There you have it, my ranking of the Doctor’s regenerations.  How would you order them?  Let me know in the comments.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2018/01/01/doctor-ranking-regenerations/feed/ 0 9854
End of year survey for 2017 http://canadianereader.com/2017/12/29/end-of-year-survey-for-2017/ http://canadianereader.com/2017/12/29/end-of-year-survey-for-2017/#respond Sat, 30 Dec 2017 01:01:37 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=9842 Yes, I know, it’s been quite some time since I posted.  Life has got away with me.  2017 wasn’t the greatest reading year for me; I really struggled to meet my GoodReads reading challenge of 80 books, and just squeezed in by the skin of my teeth. This post is based on a survey that Jamie of the Perpetual Page Turner came up with last year.  there are some great questions here to review my reading year, so I’ll give it a go again this year.

Reading Stats

Number Of Books You Read: 81 books
Number of Re-Reads:   Six I guess?
Genre You Read The Most From: YA fantasy

Best in Books

1. Best Book You Read In 2017?
This would be The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O. by Neal Stephenson and Nicole Galland.  This book’s concept combines time travel, witches, history and shadowy government organisations into an incredible story.  It’s rather hard to describe.  I loved everything about it.  The premise, the writing, the strong and fascinating characters, everything.  This is one I would recommend listening to in audiobook format.  It is narrated by a full voice cast who really brings the story to life.  I certainly recommend this book, expecially the audiobook format. 

2. Book You Were Excited About & Thought You Were Going To Love More But Didn’t?
Invictus by Claudia Gray.  I’ve loved most of Gray’s books, so I was somewhat disappointed that this book just didn’t grab me for some reason.  Pity. 

3. Most surprising (in a good way or bad way) book you read? 
Here I’ll say Lord of Shadows by Cassandra Clare.  Given my (few) gripes about her ending to The Mortal Instruments, I was pleasantly surprised to see that she went the way she did.

4. Book You “Pushed” The Most People To Read (And They Did)
This would be Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stane.  No, that is not a typo.  Philosopher’s Stane is the Scots language version of Harry’s story.  Translated by Matthew Fitt, this was a real walk down memory lane.  The translation is truly inspired.  Diagon Alley becomes the Squinty Gate and the Sorting Hat becomes the Bletherin Bunnet.  Brilliant.  Of course, if you don’t speak Scots, this may not be for you…

5. Best series you started in 2017? Best Sequel of 2017? Best Series Ender of 2017?
Series starter: The Cruel Prince by Holly Black.  I received an eArc of this book, and will almost certainly do a review.  It’s definitely worth reading.
Sequel: Lord of Shadows by Cassandra Clare.  Honestly, Clare can’t put a foot wrong.  I love these books
Series Ender.  Assassin’s Fate by Robin Hobb.  Sniff.  Hurts too much to say any more 

6. Favorite new author you discovered in 2017?
Nicola Yoon.  I read both Everything, Everything and The Sun is Also a Star and loved both of these.  Wonderful characters and writing. 

7. Best book from a genre you don’t typically read/was out of your comfort zone?
Getting Things Done: The Art of Stress Free Productivity by David Allen.  Since I moved to a new role last year, I’ve been trying to become more productive and Allen’s GTD system is deceptively simple.  I’ve really enjoyed learning more about it. 

8. Most action-packed/thrilling/unputdownable book of the year?
I’ll be honest here, given the poor reading year I’ve had there have been very few books that had me running to grab them every spare moment.  The closest I came to this was probably Kevin Hearne’s A Plague of Giants (awesome read) or Brandon Sanderson’s Oathbringer whose 1242 pages went surprisingly fast.

9. Book You Read In 2017 That You Are Most Likely To Re-Read Next Year?
Possibly Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale before series 2 is aired.

10. Favorite cover of a book you read in 2017? 
Strange the Dreamer.  Gorgeous 

11. Most memorable character of 2017?
Nona Gray of Mark Lawrence’s Red Sister.  I’m really intrigued by her and look forward to reading more about her.

12. Most beautifully written book read in 2017?
Assassin’s Fate by Robin Hobb.  Of course, I’m now so invested in these characters by now that anything Hobb wrote would be layered with so much meaning. 

13. Most Thought-Provoking/ Life-Changing Book of 2017?
Here I’ll go with Getting Things Done by David Allen.  It really made me think about my productivity and my efficiency.

14. Book you can’t believe you waited UNTIL 2017 to finally read? 
Pass 

15. Favorite Passage/Quote From A Book You Read In 2017?
That final scene in the quarry of Assassin’s Fate.  Sob.
Honorable mention:  The Twelfth Doctor “Laugh hard. Run fast. Be kind. Doctor – I let you go”  Sob. Capaldi’s delivery was perfect.

16.Shortest & Longest Book You Read In 2017?
Shortest book: Christmas Present by Jodi Taylor at just 41 pages
Longest book: Brandon Sanderson’s Oathbringer at a whopping 1242 pages or 55 hours of audiobook.

17. Book That Shocked You The Most
Career of Evil by Robert Galbraith/J.K. Rowling.  I did NOT expect that ending.

18. OTP OF THE YEAR (you will go down with this ship!)
Fitz and the Fool.  Always

19. Favorite Non-Romantic Relationship Of The Year
For this one I’m going to go to television: Twelfth Doctor and Bill. Wonderful partnership.

20. Favorite Book You Read in 2017 From An Author You’ve Read Previously
Lord of Shadows by Cassandra Clare

21. Best Book You Read In 2017 That You Read Based SOLELY On A Recommendation From Somebody Else/Peer Pressure:
The Sun is Also a Star by Nicola Yoon.

22. Newest fictional crush from a book you read in 2017?
Bayek from Assassin’s Creed Desert Oath.

23. Best 2017 debut you read?
Mmmmm I don’t think I read any debuts this year.

24. Best Worldbuilding/Most Vivid Setting You Read This Year?
Artemis by Andy Weir.  Made me want to visit the Moon.

25. Book That Put A Smile On Your Face/Was The Most FUN To Read?
J.K. Rowling’s Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them.  Another audiobook recommendation.  Rowling’s humour and magic really comes across in this book and Redmayne’s delivery is perfect.  So often when listening to this book I found myself giggling out loud.

26. Book That Made You Cry Or Nearly Cry in 2017?
Assassin’s Fate, but I knew that going in.

27. Hidden Gem Of The Year?
The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O.  I hope more people discover it.

28. Book That Crushed Your Soul?
Assassin’s Fate.  Again I knew that going in.

29. Most Unique Book You Read In 2017?
The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O.  I am not aware of any other book that combines time travel, witches, history and shadowy government organisations!

30. Book That Made You The Most Mad (doesn’t necessarily mean you didn’t like it)?
The Core by Peter V. Brett.  I’d been looking forward to this so much and the pacing was so slow and the ending so rushed.  

Your Blogging Life

1. New favorite book blog you discovered in 2017?
Pass

2. Favorite review that you wrote in 2017?
My review of Robin Hobb’s Assassin’s Fate

3. Best discussion/non-review post you had on your blog?
We have a new Doctor!! My discussion of the casting of Jodie Whittaker as the Thirteenth Doctor.

4. Best event that you participated in (author signings, festivals, virtual events, memes, etc.)?
None 🙁

5. Best moment of bookish/blogging life in 2017? 
I received an eARC of Assassin’s Fate.  I literally screamed out loud when I read the email! 

6. Most challenging thing about blogging or your reading life this year?
Last year I moved to a new role at work, one which takes a lot of time and energy.  It has left me with much less time and energy for reading which is a real shame.  My blogging has been very sporadic of late due to this.  Also, I’ve not been able to take as much pleasure in it as I would like.

7. Most Popular Post This Year On Your Blog (whether it be by comments or views)?
Assassin’s Fate by Robin Hobb.

8. Post You Wished Got A Little More Love?
I’m happy if people read any of my ramblings!

9. Best bookish discovery (book related sites, book stores, etc.)?
Amazon Echo’s Alexa and her Audible integration into my life.  It is so nice to be able to control my audiobook playback by voice.  

10.  Did you complete any reading challenges or goals that you had set for yourself at the beginning of this year?
Yes.  By the skin of my teeth I completed my GoodReads challenge of reading 80 books in 2017.

Looking ahead

1. One Book You Didn’t Get To In 2017 But Will Be Your Number 1 Priority in 2018?
I am planning on completing three series:  Diana Gabaldon’s Outlander, Kevin Hearne’s Iron Druid Chronicles and Eoin Colfer’s Artemis Fowl.

2. Book You Are Most Anticipating For 2018 (non-debut)?
Queen of Air and Darkness by Cassandra Clare.

3. 2018 Debut You Are Most Anticipating?
Pass

4. Series Ending/A Sequel You Are Most Anticipating in 2018?
Queen of Air and Darkness by Cassandra Clare. 

5. One Thing You Hope To Accomplish Or Do In Your Reading/Blogging Life In 2018?
I will probably take a bit of a break from blogging in 2018.  I’m finding the pressure to write regular blog posts is robbing the activity of much of its fun.  I will probably only write when I feel I have something I wish to write about. 

6. A 2018 Release You’ve Already Read & Recommend To Everyone: 
The Cruel Prince by Holly Black.  Enjoy. 

Thanks for reading – let me know in the comments what your favourite books of 2017 were and which ones you’re most anticipating for 2018.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2017/12/29/end-of-year-survey-for-2017/feed/ 0 9842
Upcoming book releases Autumn 2017 http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/20/upcoming-book-releases-autumn-2017/ http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/20/upcoming-book-releases-autumn-2017/#respond Sun, 20 Aug 2017 23:39:44 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=9677 Hello, now that summer is drawing to a close, we’re coming into prime book release time.  As usual, I have a metric tonne of books about whose release I am super excited.  Some of these are continuations of series in which I am already invested, some are new series from authors I love and some are reissues of old favourites.  So, let’s get into it, shall we?

To kick off, I was really excited by the recent news that Raymond E.Feist has managed to resolve the ebook rights issue for North America.  While most of his newer works have been released in ebook, his earlier novels have so far been unavailable in my preferred format.  This will all change on August 22nd when his Riftwar saga as well as his Empire trilogy with Janny Wurts will be released as ebooks.  I understand audiobook format will follow later this year.  Although I have read all of these, I am very happy to add them to my collection.  I consider Feist a true master storyteller and if you are not familiar with his work, this is a great opportunity to get started.  Be aware, though,that the series does have a somewhat slow start.  It just gets better and better.  Silverthorn remains one of my favourite books by this author.

Also in August, I will get to experience the mashup of one of my favourite authors with one of my favourite characters with the release of Leigh Bardugo’s take on Wonder Woman.  I’ve always adored this superhero and I can’t wait to read Bardugo’s take on her.  Wonder Woman: Warbringer is a coming-of-age story set before Diana of Themiscyra becomes Wonder Woman.  Sounds awesome.  Wonder Woman: Warbringer is released on August 29th.

On September 5th we have the release of Tower of Dawn by Sarah J. Maas, the next instalment in the Throne of Glass series.  I think I’m unusual amongst Maas fans in that I’m more invested in the Throne of Glass series than her Court of Thorns and Roses series.  In fact, I’ve not yet read the third book in the latter series.   Tower of Dawn focusses on Chaol Westfall.  I look forward to reading about the continuation of this story.

Moving onto October, and this is going to be a really painful month for my bank balance.  

At some point in October, date not yet specified, we have the release of Harry Potter in his 80th translation – Scots.  The title is Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stane.  Note this is isn’t Gaelic, but the lowland Scots dialect that I grew up hearing.  This will be a fascinating read, I’m sure. 

First off on October 3rd we have the release of the culmination of Peter V. Brett’s Demon Cycle, The Core.  I really love the wordbuidling in this series and am engaged in the stories of our protagonists  It takes a great deal of skill to write two characters who are both equally honourable, equally justified in their opposing beliefs and who both want the best for their world – and who are in direct conflict.  The previous instalment finished on a real cliffhanger, so I can’t wait to read the conclusion.

Ian Doescher will publish the next installment in his William Shakespeare’s Star Wars saga with The Force Doth Awaken on October 3rd.  In this series he reworks the Star Wars screenplays as if they were written by Shakeapeare complete with iambic pentameter.  This time I was overjoyed to see that Random House Audio is once again producing a full cast audiobook production.  Do yourselves a favour and pick up the audiobook – Shakespeare (and Star Wars) are not meant to be read but to be experienced through performance, and if previous instalments are any guide, this will knock it out of the park.  These audiobooks are presented like a radio production and the production values are incredible.  I can’t recommend them highly enough and can’t wait to listen to this one.

Robert Langdon returns on October 3rd in Dan Brown’s latest novel, Origin.  While I wouldn’t call Brown’s writing great literature, they are very entertaining reads and I’m looking forward to this one.

Also on October 3rd we have the release of Ringer by Lauren Oliver.  This is the sequel to Replica.  While I didn’t find the characters or plot of Replica anything special, I was intrigued by the format;  the book can be read in multiple ways.  Either you can read Gemma’s story through first, or Lyra’s – or read them chapter by chapter.  This is enough to make make me want to read the second book.  

October 10th is the book birthday of Cassandra Clare and Holly Black’s The Silver Mask. This is the fourth in the Harry Potteresque Magisterium series.  The synopsis for this book is very vague about the magic and the mystery intesifying.  I have really enjoyed this series so far, and am looking forward to the continuation.

All the Crooked Saints by Maggie Stiefvater is another book I’m anticipating.  This is a new series from the creator of the The Raven Cycle., which gave me such a book hangover.  I don’t know much about the new series, except that it’s set in Colorado.  Stiefvater’s name is enough for me to autobuy.  All the Crooked Saints is released on October 10th.

Kevin Hearne, author of The Iron Druid Chronicles, has a new seriesstarting off entitled A Plague of Giants.  Unlike in the Iron Chronicles Hearne has created a completely new world for this series in addition to a new mythology.  The synopsis indicates that one of the main characters is a kickass warrior and mother.  I’m interested to see how Hearne handles a female protagonist.  A Plague of Giants is also released on October 10th.

After a break of nearly 17 years, Philip Pullman is returning to his Dark Materials world with a new trilogy entitled the La Belle Sauvage. He describes it as an “equel” rather than sequel or prequel.  It will return to Lyra’ story both before she came to Oxford and as a young woman in her twenties.  I note that Michael Sheen is narrating the audiobook.  I’m a little surprised we don’t have a female narrator, but I’m sure it’ll be great anyway.  The first book in the trilogy, The Book of Dust will be published on October 19.

Moving onto November we have the release of Renegades by Marissa Meyer.  This is a new superhero series from the writer of the Lunar Chronicles.  Again an auto buy for me.  Renegades will be published on November 7th.

Next up we have Oathbreaker by Brandon Sanderson. This is the third book in Sanderson’s epic fantasy The Stormlight Archive.  This is another bookstopper at 1200+ pages or 49 hours of listening.  I might consider listening to the Graphic Audio adaptations of the earlier books to get caught up.  Still, it’s another auto buy for me, despite the fact that I’m not reading much epic fantasy these days.  Oathbringer is released on November 14th.

The final book I have on my upcoming releases list is Artemis by Andy Weir, the writer of the Martian.  I LOVED the blend of science and character development in the Martian and I”m hoping for more from Artemis.  Artemis is also released on November 14th.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/20/upcoming-book-releases-autumn-2017/feed/ 0 9677
Invictus by Ryan Graudin – Review http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/06/invictus/ http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/06/invictus/#respond Sun, 06 Aug 2017 21:48:03 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=9659 I was lucky enough to receive an advanced Netgalley copy of Invictus by Ryan Graudin – thanks so much to Hachette for giving me a copy.  I ADORED Graudin’s earlier series Wolf by Wolf so I was very excited to read Invictus.Invictus is described as young adult time-travel adventure with a dash of Doctor Who (guys, you already had me at “Ryan Graudin,” no need for overkill) and Firefly.  So without further ado, here’s my review.

What I liked

Characters

From my enjoyment of her previous books, character development is one of Graudin’s strengths as a writer and this is borne out by those we meet in Invictus.  I really enjoyed them all and was very much invested in their journeys, romances and challenges.  Each person was nicely developed with his or her quirks, wishes and weaknesses.  The interrelationships between them all were very well done and I really enjoyed seeing how they developed.  Certain characters start out as quasi antagonists, but by the end, I came to care for them as much as for our heroes.

Plot

Without saying too much – spoilers!- I did like where Graudin went with the storyline.  There are some really nicely done twists.  Enjoy.

What I didn’t like

Worldbuilding 

Don’t get me wrong; I loved what we got in terms of worldbuilding. The world and story did fit together well.  However, I would have liked a lot more.  There was so much we didn’t know about the world Graudin has created and the book was the poorer for it.  For example, time travel; awesome!  But what are the rules in this world?  What are the consequences of breaking those rules?  What are the limitations?  As I’ve said often before, you can learn as much about a system by what you can’t do as what you can do.  To return to that old chestnut, can you go back and kill Hitler in Far’s world?  These are all questions I had which weren’t answered in the book.  I think I see where Graudin was going, but I would have liked a fuller explanation.

In a similar vein, I would have loved to have seen some of Far’s and his friends’ adventures prior to the attempted heist that started this particular story.  I would have enjoyed seeing his crew handle a couple of successful missions.  It would also have added to the character development.

I would have liked to have seen this as a duology, with expanded worldbuilding and more shenanigans developed.  There is a natural breaking point halfway through the book which would have been an excellent point to make the reader wait to build excitement for the second part.   

All in all, I really enjoyed Invictus and gave it four stars out of five.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/06/invictus/feed/ 0 9659
Update on the Amazon Echo and Home Automation http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/02/update-amazon-echo-home-automation/ http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/02/update-amazon-echo-home-automation/#respond Thu, 03 Aug 2017 00:51:26 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=9652 Hello, I thought I’d give you an update into my adventures in the Amazon Echo and home automation.  I’m still really enjoying my virtual assistant.  Since my last post I’ve added a few more items to my home automation setup.  My home now includes two Philips Hue Bloom lights, a Philips Hue Go (thank you, employer, for your rewards program 😀 ) a Harmony hub and a second Amazon Echo Dot for our bedroom.  My husband prefers more tried and true methods of controlling our home, but even he has occasionally tried having Alexa control stuff.  It certainly amuses him when Alexa doesn’t quite… perform as expected shall we say.

The part of my home automation setup I love the most is my Philips Hue lights.  Being able to play around with them is awesome and they can make such a difference to my room.  I think I’ve just about resolved my issue with being able to set scenes with Alexa – you do need to be quite particular with the syntax you use unfortunately.  Once I got that down it was much easier.  The addition of the Harmony hub made combining routines much easier.  Now I can say Alexa, set bedtime and she will turn off the living room lights, turn on a nightlight in the bathroom and turn on the bedroom lights to a gentle glow for me.  

I also tried to configure geolocation as well so that our hall lights will turn on as soon as I (or to be more specific, my iPhone) gets near home.  I only set it up a couple of days ago and so far I’ve not been out after dark to test it.  We lead a quiet life!

My impression of the Harmony hub is somewhat mixed.  I’ve not had the time to really configure it yet.  I’ve set it up to do some basic things like turn on and off my TV and dim the lights, but configuration of it to work perfectly will take a bit of time.  I’ll continue to work on it though.  I do like how it combines managing my entertainment systems and my Philips Hue lights together, so that one command will turn on the TV and Apple TV, switch to Netflix and dim the lights.  It’s neat.

I really wish Amazon would provide support for the Echo in Canada.  There’s a lot you can do, but also a lot that is missing, specifically location based information.  It would be lovely not to have to add “in Montreal” when asking for the weather or to be able to ask when the local Home Depot is open.  My Alexa goal is to be able to ask her when the next number 57 bus to town will leave!

Let me know of your experiences with home automation in the comments.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2017/08/02/update-amazon-echo-home-automation/feed/ 0 9652
Reading roundup – July 29th 2017 http://canadianereader.com/2017/07/29/reading-roundup-july-29th-2017/ http://canadianereader.com/2017/07/29/reading-roundup-july-29th-2017/#respond Sat, 29 Jul 2017 21:36:05 +0000 http://canadianereader.com/?p=9635 Hello and here I am with another reading roundup.  I must admit I’ve not been doing very well with my reading.  I’m actually three books behind on my GoodReads 2017 reading challenge; 42 books out of 50.  This is due to a couple of things.  I’ve recently become obsessed with playing Assassin’s Creed on my Playstation and watching gameplay YouTube videos.  Sigh.  Honestly, I’m not so violent in real life.  Additionally, I’ve listened to more audiobooks that I have read ebooks, which always takes longer.  That’s my excuse anyway!  So, onto the roundup.

The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O. by Neal Stephenson and Nicole Galland

I absolutely ADORED this book.  I wish I had more stars than 5 to give it.  I would strongly recommend experiencing this in the audiobook version; it’s narrated by a full cast who really brings an extra je ne sais quoi to the story.  Forgive me if I misspell some of the names since I only listened to it.  In in a similar vein to the Illuminae files the story is told both through standard narration and letters, office memos, briefing files etc.  

The story is rather difficult to summarise into a few words; secret government organisations, time travel, Schroedinger’s cat, magic, witches.  I loved, loved, loved it.  Fair warning, you do need to concentrate to keep the various plots and timelines clear in your head.  The whole time travel/magic concept was very well written and I very much appreciated that it had built in limitations.  

The characters, too, are wonderfully engaging.  Each of them is well developed and the motivations for their actions are believable and logical, even for those who end up as antagonists, purely because they are opposed to our protagonists.  I loved Erszebet.  She’s fun an plucky, but her story is very sad when you think about it.  

There is also quite a bit of humour – especially in the memos from the office manager as D.O.D.O. is on the rise and red tape starts to take hold.  Many times I found myself giggling out loud.  The voice actress portraying said office manager did an awesome job at portraying her suppressed frustration that D.O.D.O. doesn’t quite fit the mould of her usual employer.  

I gave The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O. five stars out of five, not surprisingly.  Go check this out immediately.

Doctor Who: The Tenth Planet by the BBC

Those Whovians among you will know that the BBC erased many of the earlier episodes of Doctor Who because they needed the tapes and didn’t think the episodes were worth saving.  The First Doctor’s last serial, The Tenth Planet is one of the victims of this purging.  Only the last few minutes of his regeneration exist.  

However, the audio files still remain, and the BBC has released these as an audiobook with additional narration by former Companion Anneke Wills to fill in the blanks.  It works reasonably well.  The reason I picked this up is in preparation for this year’s Doctor Who Christmas special which sees current Twelfth Doctor, played by Peter Capaldi, join forces with the First Doctor, played by David Bradley.  Regeneration will be a major theme for this episode given that both Doctors are about to regenerate imminently.

In December there will be a novelisation released of the story which I shall also pick up.

I gave Doctor Who: The Tenth Planet three and a half stars out of five.

Thrawn by Timothy Zahn

I must admit I’m rather struggling with this one.  Still not finished it.

The Greatcoats series by Sebastien de Castell

Recently I was lucky enough to receive a couple of books from the publisher to review.  I received a copy of Tyrant’s Blade by Sebastien de Castell, the fourth book in his Greatcoats series.  As I amn’t familiar with the series, I picked up the first book, Traitor’s Blade to see what it was all about.  This series is described as kind of Three Musketeers with added magic.  I’ve only read the first one so far, but that seems a very good description.  Now, Dumas is one of my favourite authors.  I love the swashbuckling yarn, political intrigue and camaraderie and de Castell seems to have captured that very well.  Despite a few modernisms which jarred on me, I loved the narrative and banter.  I certainly intend to read the rest of the series.

I gave Traitor’s Blade five stars out of five.

Invictus by Ryan Graudin

I only received a Netgalley of this one today and I’m very much looking forward to getting into it.  Graudin’s Wolf by Wolf series has been one of my highlights of he last few years and I’m very grateful to Hachette Canada for the galley.

I don’t know much about Invictus except that it involves time travel with a nod to Doctor Who.  If I wasn’t already sold on the author, that would certainly have been enough to convince me!  Expect a review when I have finished it.

Anyway, that’s all I have today.  What are you reading this weekend?  Let me know in the comments.

]]>
http://canadianereader.com/2017/07/29/reading-roundup-july-29th-2017/feed/ 0 9635